A letter to our President - since he's so busy
A letter to Mr. Asif Ali Zardari, something I felt I had to right since he’s so busy traveling all the time, I don't think I'd be able to say all this in person.
Please note that this is a candid letter and although to the best of my abilities I've tried to provide links to most of the facts in this article, some facts may have been prompted by personal hatred and lack of conviction on my part with regards to our president's abilities. Wherever that may have happened, I apologies.
Dear Mr. President,
Earlier today, I wrote a letter to a fellow colleague of yours in the field of politics, someone who ruled this country before you. He didn’t come into power through a democratic way but then again neither did you. You simply took the back door and stood at the podium when no one was really paying any attention. Now sure you can argue that yours was a more politically correct method but I can’t help but do certain comparisons as time goes by. Allow me to elaborate.
Your predecessor, Pervaiz Musharaf was a man of the uniform, came into power through a coup, but was legally granted legislative authority by a 12member bench in the Supreme Court – you remember what a court is? No it’s not one of those places you have in your mansions and country clubs with green grass and white painted lines, it’s actually the only judicial body that had a backbone before you broke it, granted Mr. Musharaf did cripple it before you but you didn’t want it to stand up either, now did you.
Nevertheless, I do believe that Mr. Musharaf had this country’s best interest at heart. He did state that he wanted to improve the economic situation of the country and while in office from 2000 to 2008, this country did see a growth rate of 6.6%[1] (adjusted for inflation) for two consecutive years and this was coming up from a low of 4.5% in 2003 (again adjusted for inflation), and mind you he had the war on terror issues to deal with ever since 2001, so you can well imagine the difficulties he had to face. Some analysts even site 8% as a possible GDP growth number during the 2004 to 2007[2]. The growth was lead by the service sector and also industry. People were making a living, sure we could have been better but we were getting by.
Now you’ve been in office for a little over 2years and our GDP has plummeted to an all time low of 2.7% (adjusted for inflation) - my question to you is, how the hell did you manage to do all that? All the building blocks were in front of you, the foundation had been laid down, your party had majority seats in the government – you took an oath to help us live a normal economically viable life, you promised! Or didn’t you?
At the time of your government’s entry inflation is at an all time high – the consumer price index (CPI) was up by 24%, the sensitive price index (SPI) 33% and the wholesale price index (WPI) was 34%![3] And this was in 2008 to 2009, the current year we’re expecting another 11% hike on the CPI over an above last year. Upto 2007 during Musharaf’s time inflation was in single digits at 7.7%[4] (high but still bearable)
Now the question arises, if all things were going so well for us in the past 8 years of Musharaf’s rule, what in the hell happened in a matter of a few months of you taking office?
Even unemployment went up when you took office from 13.6% in 2008 to 15.2% in 2009[5] - current events in 2010 with the floods perhaps should not be taken into account, I’ll give you that one, but why Mr. President? Why?!
The more we earn the less it has become over the years – in 2007 just before you came into power the US Dollar was worth PKR60.63 this was slightly higher then PKR59.5 in 2005 but the moment you came into power the US Dollar just simply sky rocketed to PKR70.6 in 2008 and then 81.4 in 2009[6] and it now stands at PKR85.8!
When I see members from your party on television speaking on the different political talk shows all I see them doing is brushing away relevant questions asked by the opposition or the common man and bringing forth a barrage of mud slinging allegations, taunts and humiliating remarks. You even have a PPP member by the name of Sardar Abdul Qayyum (a federal minister) admit that corruption was the right of your party![7] Yup finally an honest statement from your party, sad it had to be so ugly.
There was an article the other day in the newspaper (apologies I don’t have the link to this one), where it was stated that your first term in office you spent more time abroad than you did back home, I don’t even want to think of the how much I had to pay to keep you there but why Mr. Zardari – why do you feel the need to do this? Is it because you can’t find a Sara Palin to shake hands[8] with here or is it because you can’t breathe the same air of the common man?
What I’m trying to ask you Mr. President is why are you here? Have you not made enough money for yourself? Can we not have some development from your end, do we not deserve dignity and self respect like every other human being? Why on Earth do you feel the need to leave your common man in a state of disarray at a time when you could have gained the most respect from them?
The floods have now affected close to 15,000,000 people in Pakistan (that’s close to 10% of the population). This natural disaster has claimed over 3000 lives. Your main puppet, I mean the Prime Minister Raza Gillani has stated that we have been pushed further back into the dark ages – and I thought the power issues of the country had already pushed us into pitch darkness. Are you going to be using this calamity as a reason for further unemployment and lack of effort ony our part?
So fine, you wanted to help by asking for aid – ok then answer me this If you had to go begging for money (which seems to come naturally to you), could you not have done it like a humble man. Travel by PIA perhaps, stay in a low end hotel (of course not a 3star, but perhaps a 4star, but not necessarily a suite in a five star hotel[9]). And what’s with the entire entourage that travels with you, is there really a need?
You’re the president of one of the poorest countries in the world, snap out of your dilution of greatness.
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs states very clearly that one has to be able to achieve his/her physiological needs (food, water, shelter, the basics) before he even thinks about safety, belonging, esteem or self actualization. If you’ve cared to hear the plea of the common man, all we’re asking for is the physiological and safety needs, we haven’t even asked you for much.
Please try to be a human being and do what should come naturally to us humans, try to belong, try to help, try to be honest and last of all try to be humble.
[1] http://www.indexmundi.com/pakistan/gdp_real_growth_rate.html - checked on 12th Aug 2010 (all GDP numbers taken from here)
[2] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/pk.html - Economy section checked on 12th Aug 2010
[3] http://www.statpak.gov.pk/depts/fbs/statistics/price_statistics/monthly_price_indices/mpi7/cpi_details.pdf - checked on 12th Aug 2010
[4] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/pk.html - Economy section checked on 12th Aug 2010
[5] http://www.theodora.com/wfbcurrent/pakistan/pakistan_economy.html - checked 12th Aug 2010
[6] http://www.theodora.com/wfbcurrent/pakistan/pakistan_economy.html - checked 12th Aug 2010
[7] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rz_GhVe3yBs – checked on 12th Aug 2010
[8] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkFnaFyylQ8 – checked on 12th Aug 2010
[9] http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2010/08/04/zardaris_katrina - checked on 12th Aug 2010
Please note that this is a candid letter and although to the best of my abilities I've tried to provide links to most of the facts in this article, some facts may have been prompted by personal hatred and lack of conviction on my part with regards to our president's abilities. Wherever that may have happened, I apologies.
Dear Mr. President,
Earlier today, I wrote a letter to a fellow colleague of yours in the field of politics, someone who ruled this country before you. He didn’t come into power through a democratic way but then again neither did you. You simply took the back door and stood at the podium when no one was really paying any attention. Now sure you can argue that yours was a more politically correct method but I can’t help but do certain comparisons as time goes by. Allow me to elaborate.
Your predecessor, Pervaiz Musharaf was a man of the uniform, came into power through a coup, but was legally granted legislative authority by a 12member bench in the Supreme Court – you remember what a court is? No it’s not one of those places you have in your mansions and country clubs with green grass and white painted lines, it’s actually the only judicial body that had a backbone before you broke it, granted Mr. Musharaf did cripple it before you but you didn’t want it to stand up either, now did you.
Nevertheless, I do believe that Mr. Musharaf had this country’s best interest at heart. He did state that he wanted to improve the economic situation of the country and while in office from 2000 to 2008, this country did see a growth rate of 6.6%[1] (adjusted for inflation) for two consecutive years and this was coming up from a low of 4.5% in 2003 (again adjusted for inflation), and mind you he had the war on terror issues to deal with ever since 2001, so you can well imagine the difficulties he had to face. Some analysts even site 8% as a possible GDP growth number during the 2004 to 2007[2]. The growth was lead by the service sector and also industry. People were making a living, sure we could have been better but we were getting by.
Now you’ve been in office for a little over 2years and our GDP has plummeted to an all time low of 2.7% (adjusted for inflation) - my question to you is, how the hell did you manage to do all that? All the building blocks were in front of you, the foundation had been laid down, your party had majority seats in the government – you took an oath to help us live a normal economically viable life, you promised! Or didn’t you?
At the time of your government’s entry inflation is at an all time high – the consumer price index (CPI) was up by 24%, the sensitive price index (SPI) 33% and the wholesale price index (WPI) was 34%![3] And this was in 2008 to 2009, the current year we’re expecting another 11% hike on the CPI over an above last year. Upto 2007 during Musharaf’s time inflation was in single digits at 7.7%[4] (high but still bearable)
Now the question arises, if all things were going so well for us in the past 8 years of Musharaf’s rule, what in the hell happened in a matter of a few months of you taking office?
Even unemployment went up when you took office from 13.6% in 2008 to 15.2% in 2009[5] - current events in 2010 with the floods perhaps should not be taken into account, I’ll give you that one, but why Mr. President? Why?!
The more we earn the less it has become over the years – in 2007 just before you came into power the US Dollar was worth PKR60.63 this was slightly higher then PKR59.5 in 2005 but the moment you came into power the US Dollar just simply sky rocketed to PKR70.6 in 2008 and then 81.4 in 2009[6] and it now stands at PKR85.8!
When I see members from your party on television speaking on the different political talk shows all I see them doing is brushing away relevant questions asked by the opposition or the common man and bringing forth a barrage of mud slinging allegations, taunts and humiliating remarks. You even have a PPP member by the name of Sardar Abdul Qayyum (a federal minister) admit that corruption was the right of your party![7] Yup finally an honest statement from your party, sad it had to be so ugly.
There was an article the other day in the newspaper (apologies I don’t have the link to this one), where it was stated that your first term in office you spent more time abroad than you did back home, I don’t even want to think of the how much I had to pay to keep you there but why Mr. Zardari – why do you feel the need to do this? Is it because you can’t find a Sara Palin to shake hands[8] with here or is it because you can’t breathe the same air of the common man?
What I’m trying to ask you Mr. President is why are you here? Have you not made enough money for yourself? Can we not have some development from your end, do we not deserve dignity and self respect like every other human being? Why on Earth do you feel the need to leave your common man in a state of disarray at a time when you could have gained the most respect from them?
The floods have now affected close to 15,000,000 people in Pakistan (that’s close to 10% of the population). This natural disaster has claimed over 3000 lives. Your main puppet, I mean the Prime Minister Raza Gillani has stated that we have been pushed further back into the dark ages – and I thought the power issues of the country had already pushed us into pitch darkness. Are you going to be using this calamity as a reason for further unemployment and lack of effort ony our part?
So fine, you wanted to help by asking for aid – ok then answer me this If you had to go begging for money (which seems to come naturally to you), could you not have done it like a humble man. Travel by PIA perhaps, stay in a low end hotel (of course not a 3star, but perhaps a 4star, but not necessarily a suite in a five star hotel[9]). And what’s with the entire entourage that travels with you, is there really a need?
You’re the president of one of the poorest countries in the world, snap out of your dilution of greatness.
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs states very clearly that one has to be able to achieve his/her physiological needs (food, water, shelter, the basics) before he even thinks about safety, belonging, esteem or self actualization. If you’ve cared to hear the plea of the common man, all we’re asking for is the physiological and safety needs, we haven’t even asked you for much.
Please try to be a human being and do what should come naturally to us humans, try to belong, try to help, try to be honest and last of all try to be humble.
[1] http://www.indexmundi.com/pakistan/gdp_real_growth_rate.html - checked on 12th Aug 2010 (all GDP numbers taken from here)
[2] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/pk.html - Economy section checked on 12th Aug 2010
[3] http://www.statpak.gov.pk/depts/fbs/statistics/price_statistics/monthly_price_indices/mpi7/cpi_details.pdf - checked on 12th Aug 2010
[4] https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/pk.html - Economy section checked on 12th Aug 2010
[5] http://www.theodora.com/wfbcurrent/pakistan/pakistan_economy.html - checked 12th Aug 2010
[6] http://www.theodora.com/wfbcurrent/pakistan/pakistan_economy.html - checked 12th Aug 2010
[7] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rz_GhVe3yBs – checked on 12th Aug 2010
[8] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkFnaFyylQ8 – checked on 12th Aug 2010
[9] http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2010/08/04/zardaris_katrina - checked on 12th Aug 2010
Dear Jellyman .. all that u ve stated might not be correct, lets suppose 95 % of it is correct, being impartial, there is no one to blame but us. We are the one who criticized musharraf and his counterparts, we are the one who wanted him out of his office and yes we are the one who managed to bring back this monarchy back in business where your successor is the next elected member of parliament. So getting back to the point, we have made room for these scavengers to feed on the rotting souls of a divided nation.
ReplyDeleteI am a strong supported of the Musharraf era and will always be, I am a fan of him on FB, but your whole writing is pointless on the fact that he has not done anything to be here, the whole facade of democracy is an output of effort made by civilians in form of party workers, the same judges and lawyers that u ve mentioned in first paragraph of your writing, members of the civil society and last but not he least, MEDIA which if I m not wrong u were once a part of.
We have brought our doom back sir, we have done it to ourselves.
and by we I dont mean u and I or any other Musharraf's admirer, but a larger part of this country who just cant get tired of being slaves.
Regards,
Humzie Syed
Dear Humzie,
ReplyDeleteWhat you say I cannot deny, but it is the loathing of the situation that we are currently in that I have tried to express. All facts that I have made are based on some sound reasoning and as much as I fear that most of it is brought upon ourselves by none other then us alone, I do feel that only we have the right to raise a voice and the ability to change what has happened. There is no denying that a nation gets the kind of leader that it deserves. I am as much a part of this as anyone else, but I am at least voicing the opinion and trying to make a change by pen and by other efforts.
I hope that this way more and more of us can stand up and say something one day collectively with a voice loud enough to shack the shackles of this so called democratic government's chains around our feet.
Thank you for your comment and I hope that we'll be able to make a change collective in the times to come.
I have always believed and still do that we Pakistani’s are better off with Dictators then a Democratic rule of law - When I used to share my views on the with my colleagues and friends, they used to laugh at me that I don’t know what I am talking about
ReplyDeleteI was a big fan of Musharaf once, but then he lost his way, mostly because of his stupid advisors – The man had the guts to go to India and speak the way he did, where as the current scumbag President we have, would wet his pants in such a condition
I totally agree that we are to be blamed for the current conditions and no one else. We are the one who voted for these butchers; now many of you will say that, no we didn’t vote. Now that’s a major issue as well, people think that by not using the vote they are doing justice to the country but that is not at all the case. Yes I know elections are rigged, yes I know the votes casting may be fake, but just by thinking all of this and staying back at home wont solve the problems at hand.
We all are praying that this devil should either leave or forced to leave but would that be a solution? if he will go we will be rules by the Shareef Regime, would that solve our problems ? No way!!!
The problem is that we don’t have a LEADER atleast among the current major parties available, an unless we can find one, we will keep putting ourself in the same position again and again. People might think I am an idiot, but I really think we would be better off again if there is a military coup, or a revolution. But our fellow patriots are too lazy to stand up for a Revolution which this country really need so we are left again with the only option, a Military Coup
Untill we can find a leader for this Nation – That will come from among us but we so called educated class, are too afraid to jump in this jungle of Politics, the only thing we know is to Pray to Allah, but Allah wont help us if we don’t want to help ourself !!!
Regards
RAG
Dear RAG,
ReplyDeleteI'm with you on the concept of dictatorship vs. democracy for our country. Plato even mentioned that a nation that has low education will inevitably select a government that is not worthy of leadership, because the ones who vote are not aware of the problems, it's a long long article, I'll try to find it on the net and you must read it.
But then again I don't think our people are lazy, the problem is we're pre occupied with trying to survive, as I mentioned majority of our population is trying to fullfil their physiological needs, something that is our given birth right, but at the moment it's every man for himself and that is why the collective force is not available for a revolution.
What we really need are answers, answers to questions that we have asked the government on a number of occasions. Once that time comes, then we'll be able to differentiate between what is lacking and what is apparent.
regards
jellyman
Dear Jellyman,
ReplyDeleteSO beautifully apt are your words, you ask so many right questions. Questions that "common men" think but cannot pose, cannot process.... may be they are bogged down by what goes on and on.... the perpetual cycle... the promises... the assurances.... the nuances of politics or so they are called.... this cycle keeps repeating.... no end in sight.... Is God so uninterested in us right now?
The question I ask.... are we heading towards a Hitlerian era in our beloved country?
Peace.
Jellyboy, WHO are you talking to? Aik dafa ghour karian. The presi-dent? the man with an IQ of such height that he quotes, "its not the sun that melts the glacier. its the rain!"
ReplyDeleteAnd, I'd love to read the PLATO wala article. :)
Dear Samar (fruitforbidden),
ReplyDeleteThe Plato article is actually a part of his work "The Republic" and a shorter version of it can be found on this site.
http://faculty.frostburg.edu/phil/forum/PlatoRep.htm